🧁 New Recipes Coming! Cast your vote in the poll below or request any of your favorite Amycakes Bakery recipes in the comments section!
↓ Jump to Cast Your Vote to help me choose which recipes to share.
I am currently formatting all my recipes for home kitchens (it's been quite an adjustment from baking 10+ cakes in every batch and using commercial convection ovens!). But I've found that baking from home can be therapeutic, relaxing, and rewarding.
Please sign up for my newsletter if you'd like to be notified when my recipes are ready. 😊
Cast your vote!
UPDATED 06/21/22:
Typically if I haven't yet shared a bakery recipe that is frequently requested, it means that my small-batch versions haven't turned out perfectly yet and I need to tweak and run a few more test batches. Once it is perfected I'll share it! 🙂
The poll below will help me choose which recipes to share! I'm currently planning ahead for the holiday season! Please cast your vote below.
Thanks for Reading. ❤️
Do you have a favorite Amycakes dessert?
Please let me know what Amycakes treat you would love to make at home! Either cast your vote in the poll above, or leave a comment below so I know which recipes to post about first.
Christine Poirier says
Vanilla Almond and Variations and also Golden Vanilla!
Amy says
Awesome, thank you!
Alise says
Lemon and strawberry cake recipes please!
Lenord says
You cinnamon rolls are heaven!! I would love to see a recipe, but they will still not do your justice!! Many Christmas mornings have started with your cinnamon rolls!
Chris says
Lemon recipe please!
Kaitlyn says
Triple berries and cream cake, orange almond cupcakes and Italian cream cupcakes!! That would be so amazing thank you!
Stacey says
Your cinnamon roll recipe and the fresh strawberry cake recipe!
Jessica Pitts says
Vanilla Almond!!!! How I miss that beautiful recipe!
Virginia says
I would love to have your Cinnamon Roll recipe. I always looked forward to stopping by for a fresh cinnamon roll weekly. After I moved away I would always buy a pan of rolls to share with family while visiting. I would also love your strawberry cake, vanilla cake, and coconut cake recipes. Thank you so much!
Erica says
I would love the recipe for the cinnamon rolls! My brother served your cinnamon rolls instead of cake at his wedding, and it was always a staple at work retirement parties!
BJ says
Your strawberry lemonade cake was amazing. It is how I celebrated each birthday I had while in Springfield for school. Your bakery was one of very few things that made Springfield enjoyable while I was there for school. Thank you so much!
Ryan says
Your chocolate ganache cheesecake cake please! I got this for my wife for her birthday the last 2 years and she was devastated when i couldn't get it for her this year.
Kimberly Moody says
The seasonal Red, White, and Blueberry cake, Peanut Butter Fudge
Karen says
Could you kindly provide the recipes for your Banana Cake and your Strawberry Cake? Your Coconut Cake is also fabulous, that would be great if you could provide that one too! Thanks so much for all your lovely cakes over the years.
Hayden says
We have been getting your frosted sugar cookies forever and they are my favorite I would love to have that recipe. I also loveee the vanilla almond cake and would love to have that recipe as well!
Wendy Russell says
I too would love the your strawberry cake recipe Amy! I would also love your recipe for your key lime pie cupcakes.
Anonymous says
Cake truffles! Also Vanilla almond, coconut cream, and chocolate. Good chocolate cake is super hard to make/find a solid recipe for and yours is great.
Anne says
Golden caramel craze cake recipe please. Always reminded me of my grandmother! Thanks for the website.
Ashley Cozad says
Cheesecake cakes please!!!
Jennifer says
My sister has ordered a lemon cake (with curd) for her wedding anniversary every year since 2012. It would be an amazing anniversary gift for her to be able to keep up that tradition with a homemade version. Thanks for the memories!
Lori says
Oh my, how do you choose just one? Vanilla Almond, Strawberry, Banana and Carrot please! 🥰
Lori says
...and blueberry! Loved your blueberry cake too.
Shawna Conyers says
I would love the recipe for cinnamon rolls, as well as those rhubarb turnover/pies that the previous lady made! ❤️
Courtney Cross says
Golden berry cupcakes! Please!!!!
Tracy says
Chocolate Ganache Cheesecake!
Erica says
We had your Vanilla Almond on our wedding day & again for my husband’s birthday! It’s my favorite cake! 😋 Thanks for sharing your cake goodness!
Anne says
Caramel craze reminds me of my grandmother’s cake. Please add to the list of requests. Thank-you for the website. Best of luck!
Danae Van Kirk says
We would looooooove the recipe for the snickerdoodle cake, though all the cakes are delicious!!! My husband bought me two of the 9 pack cake samplers for my birthday, so I’ve tried 18 flavors and they really are ALL so good!
Anonymous says
Strawberries & Cream - can stop the daydreams about it!
Diana says
Strawberry cake, vanilla almond cake, confetti cake, cinnamon rolls!
Tayler Yarberry says
Fresh strawberry cake and coconut cake!!!! I mean, I’m here for all of them, but those are definitely my favorites 💜
Jennifer says
My favorite has always been the frosted sugar cookies and vanilla almond by far! Would love to have those recipes
Olivia Mayes says
Coconut cream!!! Lemon cream too!! Miss you guys!
Gabby says
Yes! The coconut cream is amazing. We had it for our wedding cake
Cindy says
I visited your bakery 10 years ago while on vacation in Missouri. Your cupcakes were amazing! I would love the strawberry cupcake with strawberry frosting recipe. I have never found a strawberry cupcake as good as yours. Congratulations on your new adventure.
Robin says
Your frosting is my absolute favorite!! I’m not normally a frosting eater. Vanilla almond is my favorite but your chocolate was about the only chocolate cake I’d buy. I also would LOVE your sugar cookie recipe. It’s been a LONG time since we’ve had those but used to order and get them from the case - family favorite!! Thank you so much for sharing!!! Love your tips already!
Brooke says
Strawberries and cream!
Amy says
Fresh strawberry cake with vanilla buttercream frosting please! We absolutely loved having you make this for our June 2015 wedding!
amy says
bananna, strawberry, lemon and raspberry
LeAnn says
Elvis cake is my favorite!
Melissa says
What is Elvis cake? 🙂
Ashley says
Lemon cake please!! We had this at our wedding and every anniversary since. We miss it and would love to make it this August!
Angela says
Elvis! They are so beyond delicious 😋 I need to know how to even attempt to make these like you did!
Ashley says
I’d love the golden vanilla, banana and strawberry cake recipes! 😋
ashley says
Sugar cookies! 😍
Courtney Cross says
Goldenberry cupcakes! I think they were mixed berry. I had them at a wedding and were the BEST things I ever ate. Please!
Anonymous says
Also your carrot cake is the best cake I have EVER HAD!!
Jenny Curtis says
Drew says, sugar cookies please! We miss seeing you and your cakes!
Evin says
My husband and I are so sad that you have closed. We had 5 of your single-tiered cakes for our wedding almost 2 years ago. It was such a hit! Our favorite flavors were banana, strawberry, blueberry, and peanut butter chocolate. I never got to try your coconut cream cake so I look forward to you posting that recipe as well!
Sarah Hofseth says
Amy!!! I need, like really NEED, your lemon cake recipe for our 9th anniversary. Its June 21st!
Amanda says
I know it’s not Christmas time but the chocolate peppermint cake is my all time favorite cake!! But all the boys in my house would love for me to make the Elvis ❤️❤️
Amy says
Thank you, I'll be sure to post it in time for Christmas!
Sam Carlson says
Your cakes will FOREVER be my favorite- there’s no other bakery that has ever come close. Some of my out of town relatives STILL talk about how delicious our wedding cake was almost 8 years later. I hope to make your golden vanilla in the future- my absolute favorite. 🤍
Amy says
Thanks so much Sam! 🙂
Megan Ledbetter says
I absolutely love all of your cakes but would love to learn the recipe to the snickerdoodle and strawberry cakes!! They are the best cakes I have ever had and wanna recreate them for my husband and I’s wedding anniversary! Thank you and so sad to hear you are no longer open.
Amy says
Thanks so much Megan! That's so nice to hear! 🙂
Jessa says
We would love the vanilla Almond cake !
Amy says
Thank you Jessa!
Makayla says
You all have made the best cakes I’ve ever tasted! So sad to hear you are closing, but thankful to learn from your experience and tips! Our wedding cake was made by you and it was coconut cream. I would love to have your coconut cream cake recipe!
Amy says
Thanks so much Makayla!
Rebecca says
We have loved your bakery and have celebrated many occasions with an Amycake. My favorite is the Neapolitan. We moved to Tennessee a year ago and are coming back for a visit. I got on your website to order a cake for the occasion. My tastebuds are so sad. However, glad for you to be doing something new. Thank you for sharing some of your tips!!! I would love to have your strawberry cake recipe.
Amy says
Thank you Rebecca! I'll be sure the share the fresh strawberry! 🙂
Emily says
I would loooove the Fresh Blueberry Recipe! It was so so yummy
Amy says
Thank you Emily! I think the Fresh Blueberry was my favorite Amycakes seasonal flavor. 🙂
Christian says
You are so kind to share your recipes and your process. My family misses your cakes so much. We are so glad to at least get to try to make something similar to your cakes. Thank you so much and bless you.
Amy says
Thank you Christian! I'm excited to share them in just a couple weeks!
Kaleigh says
Vanilla Almond hands down!! I miss it sooo much already!
Amy says
Thank you Kaleigh! 🙂